Skip to content

Writing a Nursing Research Article Critique

A nursing research article critique is a critical evaluation and analysis of a published research article in the field of nursing. It involves assessing the strengths, weaknesses, and overall quality of the study. The purpose of a critique is to evaluate the research methodology, data collection and analysis, results, and interpretation of findings in order to determine the credibility, relevance, and applicability of the study to nursing practice.

Review: Nursing Research Article Critique Examples

How to Critique a Nursing Research Article

Here are some pointers and tips on how to critique each key element in a nursing research article:

  1. Critiquing the Introduction:
    • Is the research problem clearly stated and well-defined?
    • Does the introduction provide a rationale for the study and explain its significance to nursing practice?
  2. Critiquing the Research Problem and Purpose:
    • State the problem clearly as it is presented in the report.
    • Have the investigators placed the study problem within the context of existing knowledge?
    • Will the study solve a problem relevant to nursing?
    • State the purpose of the research.
    • Assess whether the literature review adequately supports the research problem and provides a foundation for the study.
  3. Critiquing the Theoretical Framework:
    • Are the theoretical concepts defined and related to the research?
    • Does the research draw solely on nursing theory or does it draw on theory from other disciplines?
    • Is a theoretical framework stated in this research piece?
    • If not, suggest one that might be suitable for the study.
  4. Critiquing the Variables/Hypotheses/Assumptions:
    • What are the independent and dependent variables in this study?
    • Are the operational definitions of the variables given? If so, are they concrete and measurable?
    • Is the research question or the hypothesis stated? What is it?
  5. Critiquing the Literature Review:
    • Evaluate the currency and relevance of the sources cited.
    • Identify the concepts explored in the literature review.
    • Assess whether the literature review is comprehensive, considering both theoretical and empirical literature.
    • Look for any gaps in the literature that the study aims to address.
  6. Critiquing the Methodology:
    • What type of design (quantitative, qualitative, and type) was used in this study? Evaluate the appropriateness of the research design for the research question.
    • Was inductive or deductive reasoning used in this study?
    • State the sample size and study population, sampling method, inclusion/exclusion criteria, and study setting.
    • Did the investigator choose a probability or non-probability sample?
    • Evaluate the reliability and validity of the data collection tools or instruments used.
    • Assess whether ethical considerations and participant protection were adequately addressed.
  7. Critiquing the Data Analysis:
    • Evaluate whether the statistical methods used are appropriate for the research design and objectives.
    • Assess the clarity and accuracy of data analysis procedures.
    • Consider whether the statistical tests used are suitable for the type of data collected.
  8. Critiquing the Results:
    • Evaluate the presentation of results, including tables, graphs, or figures.
    • Assess whether the results address the research question and are consistent with the data collected.
    • What are the strengths and weaknesses of the study? Look for any limitations or biases in the analysis or presentation of results.
  9. Critiquing the Discussion:
    • Evaluate the interpretation of the results and their implications for nursing practice. In terms of the findings, can the researcher generalize to other populations? Explain using evidence.
    • Assess whether the discussion integrates the findings with existing knowledge.
    • Consider whether alternative explanations or limitations of the study are acknowledged.
  10. Critiquing the Conclusion:
    • Assess whether the conclusion reflects the study’s objectives and findings.
    • Evaluate the clarity and completeness of the conclusion.
    • Look for any recommendations for future research and their relevance.
  • Throughout the critique, consider the study’s strengths and weaknesses, potential biases, and any methodological or ethical issues that may impact the validity of the findings.
  • It is important to provide specific examples and evidence to support your critique.
  • Remember to maintain a balanced and objective approach, focusing on the quality and rigour of the research rather than personal opinions or biases.

Mistakes to Avoid in a Nursing Research Article Critique

When critiquing a nursing research article, it is important to avoid certain common mistakes to ensure a thorough and accurate evaluation of the study. Here are some mistakes to avoid when critiquing a nursing research article:

  1. Failing to read the article thoroughly: It is important to read the article in its entirety to gain a comprehensive understanding of the study design, methods, results, and conclusions. Skipping sections or not reading the article closely enough may lead to an incomplete or inaccurate evaluation.
  2. Being overly critical: While it is important to critically evaluate the study, it is also important to avoid being overly critical or dismissive of the study without just cause. Be objective in your evaluation and consider the strengths and limitations of the study.
  3. Ignoring ethical considerations: Ethical considerations, such as informed consent and protection of human subjects, are important to consider when critiquing a study. Ensure that the study followed ethical guidelines and consider the implications of any ethical violations.
  4. Focusing solely on the results: While the results of the study are important, they should not be the only focus of the critique. Consider the study design, methods, and conclusions, as well as the implications for nursing practice and patient care.
  5. Ignoring limitations: Limitations are a natural part of any research study, and it is important to consider and evaluate these limitations when critiquing the study. Ignoring limitations or failing to acknowledge their impact on the results can lead to an incomplete or inaccurate evaluation.
  • By avoiding these common mistakes, you can ensure a thorough and accurate evaluation of a nursing research article, and determine its validity and usefulness for nursing practice.
  • Remember, a nursing research article critique aims to provide an objective analysis of the research article, highlighting its strengths and weaknesses. It helps nurses and other healthcare professionals assess the validity, reliability, and applicability of research findings to inform evidence-based practice.

Nursing Writing Lab