Skip to content
Essay Writing
Extended Papers
Business Writing
Nursing Writing
Other Writing Tips

Sample Literary Argument Essay on ‘The Cask of Amontillado’

Basics
Types
Techniques
Fallacies
Sample Essays

Below is a sample outline and a well-developed literary argument essay in MLA titled “Unleashing the Depths of Madness: A Literary Critique of Revenge, Betrayal, and Madness in Poe’s ‘The Cask of Amontillado.’” This sample is intended to help college students write better essays.

Literary Argument Essay on ‘The Cask of Amontillado’

Sample Literary Argument Essay Outline on ‘The Cask of Amontillado’

  1. Introduction:
    • Hook or attention-grabbing statement
    • Background information on “The Cask of Amontillado” and its author, Edgar Allan Poe
    • Thesis statement: Through its exploration of revenge, betrayal, and the theme of madness, “The Cask of Amontillado” serves as a chilling examination of the dark depths of human psychology.
  2. Body Paragraphs:
    1. Main Point 1: Analysis of Montresor’s motive for revenge
      • Topic sentence: Montresor’s motive for seeking revenge is rooted in a perceived insult that challenges his pride and honor.
      • Evidence: Montresor’s account of Fortunato’s insult and his resolve to avenge it.
      • Example: “The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult, I vowed revenge.” (Poe 1)
      • Analysis: Montresor’s firm resolve to avenge Fortunato’s insult reveals his deep-seated resentment and the driving force behind his revenge. His obsession with vengeance showcases the depths of his malevolence and madness.
      • Counterargument and Rebuttal: While some may argue that Montresor’s actions are driven by personal madness rather than a genuine grievance, the calculated nature of his revenge and his deliberate manipulation of Fortunato suggest a carefully crafted plan rooted in a twisted sense of justice.
    2. Main Point 2: Examination of the theme of betrayal
      • Topic sentence: The theme of betrayal is central to the narrative, as Montresor deceives and manipulates Fortunato.
      • Evidence: Montresor’s friendly demeanor and false concern for Fortunato’s health.
      • Example: “My dear Fortunato, you are luckily met… I have received a pipe of what passes for Amontillado, and I have my doubts.” (Poe 4)
      • Analysis: Montresor’s friendly demeanor and false concern for Fortunato’s health serve as a deceitful façade, concealing his true intentions. This act of betrayal adds to the chilling atmosphere of the story, underscoring the sinister nature of Montresor’s plan.
      • Counterargument and Rebuttal: Critics may argue that Fortunato’s arrogance and pride make him deserving of his fate. However, the story raises questions about the ethics of Montresor’s actions and the extent to which betrayal can be justified.
    3. Main Point 3: Exploration of the theme of madness
      • Topic sentence: “The Cask of Amontillado” delves into the theme of madness, both in terms of Montresor’s psychological state and the reader’s experience.
      • Evidence: Montresor’s obsession with revenge and his macabre pleasure in carrying out his plan.
      • Example: “A wrong is unredressed when retribution overtakes its redresser. It is equally unredressed when the avenger fails to make himself felt as such to him who has done the wrong.” (Poe 3)
      • Analysis: Montresor’s obsession with revenge and his macabre pleasure in carrying out his plan reveal his descent into madness. The dark humor he exhibits and his distorted sense of morality further illustrate the depths of his psychological state. The story’s narrative structure and eerie atmosphere also contribute to the reader’s immersion in a world permeated by madness.
      • Counterargument and Rebuttal: Some may argue that Montresor’s actions can be attributed to temporary insanity or a response to Fortunato’s provocation. However, the calculated nature of his plan and his ability to recount the events in detail suggest a deeper, more sinister form of madness.
  3. Conclusion
    • Restatement of the thesis and main points: “The Cask of Amontillado” serves as a chilling examination of the dark depths of human psychology through its exploration of revenge, betrayal, and the theme of madness.
    • Final thoughts on the enduring impact of the story and its ability to unsettle readers.
    • Concluding statement emphasizing the significance of “The Cask of Amontillado” as a testament to Poe’s mastery of psychological suspense and his portrayal of the human capacity for malevolence.

Remember, a literary argument essay goes beyond the analysis of the text and involves making a specific argument or thesis statement about the work. While analysis is still an important part of a literary argument essay, the primary focus is on presenting a persuasive argument and supporting it with evidence and reasoning.

In a literary argument essay, you take a stance on an interpretive or evaluative question related to the text and provide reasons and evidence to support your position. You engage in a critical dialogue with the text and other literary critics to present and defend your argument.

Other Essay Examples